Show and hide columns with the "Sort" button.
For best results in a mobile device, check (√) one column at a time due to limited screen size.
Ingredients |
Use For |
Onset |
Duration |
Pros |
Cons |
Our Take |
User Votes |
Avg. Cost |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tylenol Cold + Flu® |
TYLENOL® Cold + Flu Severe Day/Night Caplets (Daytime): Caplets (Nighttime): TYLENOL® Cold + Flu Severe Caplets: Liquid: TYLENOL® Cold Max Daytime Caplets: TYLENOL® Cold + Head Severe Caplets: TYLENOL® Sinus + Headache Daytime Caplets TYLENOL® Sinus Severe Daytime Caplets TYLENOL® Cold Max Nighttime Liquid (Cool Burst): TYLENOL® Cold + Mucus Severe COOL BURST® Liquid: TYLENOL® Cold Max Daytime Citrus Burst Liquid: TYLENOL® Cold + Sore Throat COOL BURST® Liquid |
Depending on ingredients - Temporarily relieves these common cold/flu symptoms: Minor aches and pains, headache, sore throat, nasal congestion, cough, sinus congestion and pressure, helps clear nasal passages, promotes nasal and sinus drainage, fever. |
30 mins average. Depending on symptoms. Headache usually goes first. If nose still stuffed up after 1 hour, that means it is not working. |
4 to 6 hours |
We particularly like the Liquid Cool Bursts® formulations. Especially the one for sore throat. It has a unique blend that soothes the throat for adequate relief. Stick to brand name. Store brands do not have this unique blend and do not work the same. Trust us. Tylenol did not pay us for this. It is our duty to give you the right information. |
Not as effective for stuffy nose as preparations containing pseudoephedrine. If mainly stuffy nose, prefer medications with pseudoephedrine or get a decongestant nasal spray. |
Take this if headache is the main cold symptom you are experiencing. For Tylenol Cold + Sore Throat®, Stick with the brand name. Store brands not as effective and varies from store to store. |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
Retail Pharmacy Price: |
Vicks® |
NYQUIL™ COLD & FLU NIGHTTIME RELIEF LIQUICAPS™ NYQUIL™ SEVERE COLD & FLU CAPLETS NYQUIL™/DAYQUIL™ COLD & FLU RELIEF LIQUICAPS™ Nyquil: LIQUICAPS™ Dayquil: DAYQUIL™ COLD & FLU RELIEF LIQUICAPS™ DAYQUIL™ SEVERE COLD & FLU RELIEF CAPLETS DAYQUIL™ HBP COLD & FLU LiquiCaps NYQUIL™ COLD & FLU NIGHTTIME RELIEF LIQUID NYQUIL™ SEVERE COLD & FLU RELIEF LIQUID NYQUIL™ HBP COLD & FLU Liquid DAYQUIL™ COLD & FLU RELIEF LIQUID DAYQUIL™ SEVERE COLD & FLU RELIEF LIQUID |
Depending on ingredient, temporarily relieves common cold/flu symptoms: Nasal congestion, Sinus congestion & pressure, Cough, Minor aches & pains, Headache, Fever, Sore throat, Runny nose & sneezing, swelling of nasal passages. |
About 30 minutes |
Every 4 to 6 hours |
Popular for night time cold symptoms. |
Not as effective for stuffy nose compared to preparations with pseudoephedrine or decongestant nasal spray. |
If severe stuffy nose, you may have to combine this with a decongestant nasal spray for adequate relief of stuffy nose. Good for night time cough. But will not help with stuffy nose. |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Sudafed PE® |
SUDAFED PE® PRESSURE+PAIN+COLD Caplet: SUDAFED PE® PRESSURE+PAIN+COUGH Caplet: SUDAFED PE® PRESSURE+PAIN+MUCUS Caplet: |
Depending on the ingredients, temporarily relieves these symptoms due to the common cold: Nasal congestion, headache, minor aches and pains, cough, sore throat, fever, helps loosen phlegm (mucus). |
About 30 mins. If it's past 1 hour and no relief for stuffy nose, get a decongestant nasal spray. Don't wait. It means it is not working. |
4 to 6 hours |
Get Sudafed® behind the pharmacy counter if you have stuffy nose and sinus pressure or pain and want to breathe. |
We can only recommend Sudafed® behind the pharmacy counter. |
- - - - |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Theraflu® |
Theraflu® ExpressMax® Daytime Severe Cold & Cough Caplets Theraflu® ExpressMax® Nighttime Severe Cold & Cough Caplets Theraflu® ExpressMax®Severe Cold & Flu Caplets Theraflu® Multi-Symptom Severe Cold Hot Liquid Powder Theraflu® Nighttime Multi-Symptom Severe Cold Hot Liquid Powder Theraflu® Daytime Severe Cold & Cough Hot Liquid Powder Theraflu® Nighttime Severe Cold & Cough Hot Liquid Powder Theraflu® Flu & Sore Throat Hot Liquid Powder Theraflu® ExpressMax®Severe Cold & Flu Syrup Theraflu® ExpressMax® Daytime Severe Cold & Cough Syrup Theraflu® ExpressMax® Nighttime Severe Cold & Cough Syrup Theraflu® ExpressMax® Flu, Cough & Sore Throat Syrup |
Depending on the ingredients, temporarily relieves these symptoms due to a cold: Minor aches and pains, minor sore throat pain, headache, nasal and sinus congestion, cough, fever |
Average 30 minutes. |
Every 4 to 6 hours |
Packet in hot water as vehicle helps open the sinuses and thin mucus faster compared with pills or syrups. |
Theraflu® Max-D was very good. Don't know when it will become available. |
Prefer the packets in hot water . It opens the sinuses and thin mucus faster than pills or syrups. |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Alka-Seltzer Plus® |
ALKA-SELTZER® PLUS NIGHT COLD & FLU LIQUID GELS ALKA-SELTZER® PLUS DAY COLD & FLU LIQUID GELS ALKA-SELTZER® PLUS COLD & COUGH LIQUID GELS ALKA-SELTZER® PLUS SEVERE COUGH, MUCUS & CONGESTION DAY LIQUID GELS ALKA-SELTZER® PLUS SEVERE COUGH, MUCUS & CONGESTION NIGHT LIQUID GELS ALKA-SELTZER® PLUS SEVERE SINUS, COLD & COUGH LIQUID GELS ALKA-SELTZER PLUS SEVERE SINUS, ALLERGY & COUGH LIQUID GELS ALKA-SELTZER PLUS SEVERE SINUS CONGESTION & COUGH DAY & NIGHT LIQUID GELS ALKA-SELTZER PLUS MULTI-SYMPTOM COLD & COUGH EFFERVESCENT TABLETS ALKA-SELTZER PLUS MULTI-SYMPTOM COLD NIGHT EFFERVESCENT TABLETS ALKA-SELTZER PLUS COLD SPARKLING ORIGINAL EFFERVESCENT TABLETS ALKA-SELTZER PLUS SEVERE COLD & FLU EFFERVESCENT TABLETS ALKA-SELTZER PLUS SEVERE COLD + FLU DAY Hot Drink Mix ALKA-SELTZER PLUS SEVERE COLD + FLU NIGHT Hot Drink Mix |
Depending on the ingredients, temporarily relieves these symptoms due to a cold or flu: Minor aches and pains, headache, nasal and sinus congestion, cough, sore throat, runny nose , sneezing, fever. |
30 mins average |
4 to 6 hours |
Effervescent tablets for people who cannot swallow tablets. Choice between aspirin or acetaminophen. Know that effervescent tablets contain aspirin (except for severe cold & flu), liquid-gels contain acetaminophen. |
Hard to tell which product contain Aspirin or Acetaminophen without reading the ingredients. Wish they had acronyms like ASP, APAP, HBP and so on to tell which is aspirin, acetaminophen, blood pressure. |
--- Know that effervescent tablets contain aspirin. Not for use in children less than 12 yrs of age. |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Mucinex® |
Mucinex Fast-Max Cold, Flu & Sore Throat Caplets Mucinex® Fast-Max® Severe Congestion & Cough Caplets Mucinex Day Time Congestion & Cough + Night Time Cold & Flu Caplets Mucinex® Fast-Max® Day Severe Cold & Night Cold & Flu Caplets MUCINEX® Fast-Max® Severe Cold Caplets MUCINEX® Fast-Max® Congestion & Headache Caplets Mucinex® Fast-Max® Cold, Flu & Sore Throat Liquid Gels Mucinex® Fast-Max® Day Severe Cold & Night Cold & Flu Liquid Gels Mucinex® Fast-Max® Night Time Cold & Flu Liquid Gels MUCINEX® Fast-Max® Severe Cold Liquid Gels MUCINEX® Fast-Max® Congestion & Headache Liquid Gels Mucinex® Fast-Max® Cold, Flu & Sore Throat Liquid Mucinex® Fast-Max® Clear & Cool, Severe Congestion & Cough Liquid Mucinex® Fast-Max® Clear & Cool, Cold, Flu & Sore Throat Liquid Mucinex® Fast-Max® Night Time Cold & Flu Liquid Mucinex® Fast-Max® Severe Congestion & Cough Liquid Mucinex® Fast-Max® DM Max Liquid MUCINEX® Fast-Max® Severe Cold Liquid MUCINEX® Fast-Max® Congestion & Headache Liquid |
Depending on ingredients, temporarily relieves these common cold and flu symptoms: Nasal congestion ■ minor aches and pains ■ headache ■ cough■ sore throat ■ runny nose and sneezing■ fever |
About 30 mins. |
Every 4 to 6 hours |
The cool burst is great if you have nasal and sinus congestion. But you have to be a fan of mint flavor to try it. |
Stay away from the clear and cool if you don't like mint flavor. May be too minty and make you want to throw up. |
A good choice if you have chest congestion and cough along with other cold symptoms. But we still recommend Mucinex D behind the pharmacy counter if you have nasal and chest congestion. |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Mucinex D® |
Regular: Guaifenesin 600 mg, Pseudoephedrine HCL 60 mg in each tablet Maximum Strength: Guaifenesin 1200 mg, Pseudoephedrine HCL 120 mg in each tablet |
Temporarily relieves nasal congestion due to: |
About 30 minutes |
10 to 12 hours |
High dose of guaifenesin in a sustained release form. Sustained release form gradually loosen dried mucus which you can cough out as the medication continues to work. |
Need a government issued ID to get it at the pharmacy counter Maximum strength may be too big to swallow if you have a sore throat. Can be expensive Does not contain a cough suppressant like Mucinex DM. |
Must continue to drink lots of water while using this medication for maximum effectiveness Prefer the regular strength to the maximum strength due to tablet size - especially if you also have a sore throat. Reserve this for the last stage of a cold to thin and expectorate the dried up mucus. Do not get this at the beginning of a cold |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Advil® |
Cold & sinus Ibuprofen 200 mg, Pseudoephedrine HCL 30 mg in each tablet or liquid gel. Allergy Sinus Ibuprofen 200 mg, Pseudoephedrine HCL 30 mg, Chlorpheniramine maleate 2 mg in each caplet. Sinus Congestion and Pain Ibuprofen 200 mg, Phenylephrine HCL 10 mg in each tablet. Allergy & Congestion Relief Ibuprofen 200 mg, Phenylephrine HCL 10 mg, Chlorpheniramine maleate 4 mg in each tablet. |
Depending on ingredient, temporarily relieves these symptoms associated with hay fever or other upper respiratory allergies and the common cold: |
30 minutes |
6 to 8 hours |
Anti inflammatory properties helps with inflamed sinuses and pain |
Stick with those behind the pharmacy counter that contain pseudoephedrine |
Ask for the first two with pseudoephedrine at the pharmacy counter. They are more effective for sinus pressure and stuffy nose. |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Aleve-D® |
Aleve-D Sinus & Cold Naproxen sodium 220 mg (naproxen 200 mg)(NSAID), Pseudoephedrine HCl 120 mg in each caplet. Aleve-D Sinus & Headache Naproxen sodium 220 mg (naproxen 200 mg)(NSAID), Pseudoephedrine HCl 120 mg in each caplet. |
--- Headache, Body Aches |
30 minutes |
8 to 12 hours average |
Require less daily dosing compared to competition. |
Sinus and Cold, Sinus and Headache --- All the same thing. Not for runny nose, cough or chest congestion relief. |
Take this if you are experiencing mainly sinus pressure and pain with stuffy nose. Will not work with runny nose, cough or chest congestion |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Contac® |
Contac® Cold + Flu Day Acetaminophen 500mg, Phenylephrine HCL 5mg in each caplet. Contac® Cold + Flu Night Acetaminophen 500mg, Chlorpheniramine maleate 2mg, Phenylephrine HCL 5mg in each caplet. Contac® Cold + Flu Night Cooling Relief Liquid Acetaminophen 500mg, Dextromethorphan HBr 15 mg, Doxylamine succinate 6.25 mg in each 15 ml. |
Depending on ingredients, temporarily relieves common cold/flu symptoms: headache, cough, fever, sore throat, runny nose and sneezing, minor aches and pains |
30 minutes |
4 to 6 hours |
Simple product line. Good reviews. |
- - - - |
Keeping the product line simple is a plus for people who like Contac® before the cold medicine reformulations. |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Coricidin HBP® |
CORICIDIN® HBP CHEST CONGESTION & COUGH Dextromethorphan HBR 10 mg, Guaifenesin 200 mg in each softgel. CORICIDIN® HBP COLD & FLU Acetaminophen 325 mg, Chlorpheniramine maleate 2mg in each tablet. CORICIDIN® HBP COUGH & COLD Chlorpheniramine maleate 4mg, Dextromethorphan HBR 30 mg in each tablet. CORICIDIN® HBP MAXIMUM STRENGTH FLU Acetaminophen 500 mg, Chlorpheniramine maleate 2mg, Dextromethorphan HBR 15 mg in each tablet. CORICIDIN® HBP DAY & NIGHT MULTI-SYMPTOM COLD DAY: CORICIDIN® HBP NIGHTTIME MULTI-SYMPTOM COLD Liquid |
Depending on ingredients, temporary relief of cold symptoms of: |
30 minutes |
4 to 6 hours |
Decongestant free for people with high blood pressure. But don't depend on it if you have nasal congestion. Key word is decongestant free! |
No good if you have stuffy nose. |
If you have high blood pressure and nasal congestion: Borderline or Controlled? Not Controlled? |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Mucinex® Sinus Max |
Mucinex® Sinus-Max® Pressure & Pain Caplets Mucinex® Sinus-Max® Severe Congestion Relief Caplets Mucinex® Sinus-Max® Severe Congestion Pain Liquid Gels Mucinex® Sinus-Max® Pressure & Pain Liquid Mucinex® Sinus-Max® Severe Congestion Relief Liquid Mucinex® Sinus-Max® Night Time Congestion & Cough Liquid Mucinex® Sinus-Max® Clear & Cool, Severe Congestion Relief Liquid |
Depending on the ingredients, temporarily relieves: |
30 mins. |
4 to 6 hours |
- - - - |
Too many products to choose from. Sinus Max, Fast Max, what the heck? |
- - - - |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |
Robitussin® Cold |
SEVERE MULTI-SYMPTOM COUGH COLD + FLU Liquid SEVERE MULTI-SYMPTOM COUGH COLD + FLU NIGHTTIME Liquid SEVERE COUGH + SORE THROAT Liquid MULTI-SYMPTOM COLD CF Liquid |
Depending on ingredients, temporarily relieves: Cough, Nasal Congestion, Chest Congestion, Sore Throat, Body Ache, Fever. |
30 mins. |
4 to 6 hours |
- - - - |
May be expensive for the tiny size. |
Robitussin is know for cough. Know that this has acetaminophen in a high dose (650mg). Do not take with acetaminophen. |
Did this medication help you?
What about you? |
- - - - |